Skip to content

EHRS and Ark trip shows Israel needs us to be there

By Rabbi Mark Goldsmith and Rabbi Aaron Goldstein

For the last week, we have been leading a combined group of Edgware and Hendon Reform Synagogue and Ark Synagogue members on a trip around Israel.

We have met people of diverse backgrounds – Jewish, Christian, Druze, and Muslim Palestinian citizens of Israel – in Tel Aviv, Jerusalem, Haifa and the Gaza Envelope.

What is clear is that we have had too few conversations with those people who are ‘us in Israel’. Progressive Jews. Jews who want to bring solutions and not be part of the problem. The only way to a clear understanding of the situation and what we can do to contribute is to be part of the conversation and starting that conversation means to be in Israel.

The group spent time getting to know students of all backgrounds at Tel Aviv University
The group spent time getting to know students of all backgrounds at Tel Aviv University

Appreciation of how much it meant for us to be here began at Tel Aviv University where we spoke to students Maharan, Laura and Dan (Druze, Cuban Olah and Sabra). They shared what this country means to them whether they live in a threatened village in the North, are recently arrived from Cuba or have lived here all their life.

Everyone we have spoken to expressed their appreciation for our presence, shared serious worries about the Israeli Government and told of their primary concern for the return of all the hostages now.

We travelled to the devastated Kibbutz Azza, right on the border with Gaza, together with a group of Israeli Progressive Jews whose neighbours, friends and family, asked them, ‘why’ and ‘is it safe?’ Just as we had been asked back home in London.

Singing Oseh Shalom together, British and Israeli Progressive Jews, within a kilometre of Northern Gaza, aware that shelling was continuing, was an extraordinary experience and builds our resolve that peace must come soon.

To stand in prayer at the memorial for Jake Marlowe – a young adult of EHRS who was murdered on 7 October 2023 – among the hundreds at the Nova Music Festival site meant that we had to recognise the deep trauma among all in Israel.

Ark and EHRS members held a ceremony at the Nova Festival Site for Jake Marlowe z’’l
The Ark and EHRS members held a ceremony at the Nova Festival Site for Jake Marlowe z’’l

Travelling around the country we felt safe and well looked after. We did experience one rocket attack alert at our Tel Aviv hotel in the early hours of Thursday morning. We followed the instructions given by the hotel, waited in the ‘safe space’ on the internal staircase and were back in our rooms within 10 minutes.

We were welcomed with such delight at the six Progressive synagogues nationwide that we visited. It was so heart-warming to see that clearly displayed in every synagogue was not only a facsimile of the Declaration of Independence, asserting that Israel would be a country aiming for equality, for all but also a rainbow flag or poster with the words ‘love your neighbour as yourself’ prominently inscribed. We were given one of these flags to take back to London.

Rabbi Mark Goldsmith, Rabbi Aaron Goldstein and their EHRS and Ark group with the Erez-Likhovsky, Director of Israel Religious Action Center
Rabbi Mark Goldsmith, Rabbi Aaron Goldstein and their EHRS and Ark group with Orly Erez-Likhovsky, Director of Israel Religious Action Center

There is a struggle continuing within Israel which needs our support, as was so clear when we visited the Supreme Court and the Knesset with the Israel Religious Action Center’s Director and Head of Political Advocacy. The Basic Laws – which protect the rights of all in Israel, Jews, Palestinians and all minorities such as LGBTQI+ people and refugees – are under threat. The large numbers of people whose values for Israel are so much in line with what worldwide Progressive Judaism and Progressive Zionism demand need our support.

As we approached the end of our trip we stood outside in the courtyard of the Leo Baeck Education Center in Haifa with hundreds of 16-18 year olds singing the song of hope, Eili Eili, and the Hatikva – always keeping in mind the hostages still in Gaza, whose families we had joined for Havdalah in Tel Aviv on Saturday night.

Israel needs us to be there. Israel needs our care and participation. Israel can be a place of meeting and co-existence for Jews and Arabs, for right and left – and we can go and help by visiting and strengthening the millions who share our vision.

Back To Top