The Movement for Reform Judaism

Image05.jpg
             | 
 

Movement for Reform Judaism Forum

homepost replythreaded viewhelp
 
<< Start < Prev 1 2 Next > End >>
Howard
User

Junior Boarder
Posts: 10
graphgraph
Karma: 0  
Click here to see the profile of this user
Resolved: Forum for Small Reform Congregations - 2006/07/18 22:24 Marc,

Following a discussion at Conference (last week?)- and paralleling a request from David Jacobs, can you please set up an area of the forum for discussions between 'Small Reform Congregations'. I am happy to act as a moderator of this area (can you re-enable my moderation role for "The North" forum aswell please)

We will leave it to Congregations themslves whether they define themselves as small. Here in Sheffield we have only around 60 adult members (although some 'small congregations' at the session in Leicester had perhaps 200 to 300 adult members).

I look forward to a useful exchange of information on this forum in the future.

Shalom

Post edited by: Howard, at: 2006/07/18 22:28

Post edited by: ozinm, at: 2006/12/05 10:09
Howard
Chair - Sheffield Reform
  The topic has been locked.
ozinm
Admin

Admin
Posts: 101
graphgraph
Karma: 156  
Click here to see the profile of this user
Re:Forum for Small Reform Congregations - 2006/07/19 11:33 Dear Howard,
Are you sure a forum is the best way to proceed (at least initially)?

As was pointed out by Brian Teeman in the Joomla demonstration at Conference it’s looks a little embarrassing to have a forum that is seldom used.

In fact I was thinking of amalgamating the North, Cheder Teachers, Office Administrators, Database Administrators and Web Administrators forums into a single “Synagogue Support” forum as they don’t generate much (if any) activity.

It might be better to start of with providing resources for small congregations and some regular news to generate some interest.

If we see the Synagogue Support forum being swamped with Small Communities postings then it would make sense to split it off.

Of course I could be completely wrong.

If we get a lot of replies to this posting requesting a separate forum then the need is obviously there and I will of course set one up.

I look forward to hearing your (and others) views.

Best wishes

Marc
  The topic has been locked.
janet
User

Fresh Boarder
Posts: 5
graphgraph
Karma: 0  
Click here to see the profile of this user
Re:Forum for Small Reform Congregations - 2006/07/21 10:49 It is a difficult one. I was at the meeting at Leicester and it is clear that there is a wide divergence both in what communities themselves view as 'small' as well as what other interested bodies regard as 'small'. All present agreed there is far more to the issue than mere numbers of members.

Although I was not at Brian’s presentation and therefore did not hear the full discussion, I quite agree with his views on this issue.

There is no doubt that small communities have certain needs and requirements that are unique to them. But, sometimes, these may be solved by refining ideas used by other larger communities and therefore, it is quite useful also to keep up with what is around generally.

Upon reflection, especially bearing in mind the problems of defining ‘ small’, I feel Marc’s suggestion is a good way forward. Certainly, being advised of resources etc would be extremely helpful. The situation could then be reviewed in say three months and any really active forums (is that the correct plural?) be hived off.

It may also be useful to e – mail Synagogue administrators, database administrators etc about the changes, ostensibly to update them, but in reality to give them a reminder of the forum’s existence.
  The topic has been locked.
Howard
User

Junior Boarder
Posts: 10
graphgraph
Karma: 0  
Click here to see the profile of this user
Re:Forum for Small Reform Congregations - 2006/07/23 23:41 Marc - I take your point - but in this instance I would have to disagree. There aren't any other suitable areas for this discussion

As a case in point, I was trying to find my last e-mail about this issue and couldn't find it initially - well 'suggestions and requests' was about the only useful place that I could think of to raise this query - but how easy is it for anybody who attended the Small Communities session at Conference to find this thread in this area of the forum?

Also I just loooked at the 'Synagogue support' area of the forum - which has the headings:
Cheder teachers, Office admin, Membership and Web admin - none of which are in the slightest bit relevant to the discussion about the general issues of Small Communities (and of course you can't post in the general area of this forum - only in the sub-categories).

So I looked in "Reform Comunities" - that seemed like an appropriate area to use - but of course the only area to post in here is in the section headed "The North" - which again isn't appropriate.

Now I agree - that in retrospect, a single forum for "The North" may have been better than having several smaller sub-categories, (cinsidering the level of interest that we ended up with) - but I do think that creating a single forum area for "Small Communities" (whatever we end up deciding that may be)- under the "Reform Communities" section would provide a much better 'focus' for these discussions than any other area that currently exists on the Forum.

I think that it's worth a try anyway.

Regards

Howard
Howard
Chair - Sheffield Reform
  The topic has been locked.
greenward
User

Fresh Boarder
Posts: 1
graphgraph
Karma: 0  
Click here to see the profile of this user
Re:Forum for Small Reform Congregations - 2006/07/24 07:27 I agree with the general rule that you should start out with fewer forums and then specialise as needed. This keeps the users concentrated and builds a sense of community.

But here we have a group of users with common interests asking for their own "space." Although I might not check all the forums regularly, I will make sure to check in on my "small communities" colleagues, knowing that we share common issues. This is a logical extension of us all meeting at Conference.

If a specilised forum section doesn't get used, shut it down. If it becomes obvious that the posts would be useful in a more general context, move it. Unless I'm mistaken, there's no real "cost" to experimenting that way.

Regards,

Jeff

P.S. Of course, by making us work to get the forum, you ensure that we'll feel guilty enough to actually use it
  The topic has been locked.
ozinm
Admin

Admin
Posts: 101
graphgraph
Karma: 156  
Click here to see the profile of this user
Re:Forum for Small Reform Congregations - 2006/07/25 11:04 Hi Howard,
Sorry I thought I posted a reply yesterday but I must have forgotten to.

Anyhow here goes

Howard Wrote:
Also I just looked at the 'Synagogue support' area of the forum - which has the headings:
Cheder teachers, Office admin, Membership and Web admin - none of which are in the slightest bit relevant to the discussion about the general issues of Small Communities (and of course you can't post in the general area of this forum - only in the sub-categories).


I think we are addressing the same problem. What I propose is we get rid of Cheder teachers; Office admin; Membership and Web admin + any other synagogue support areas and have one BIG area for synagogue support.
Any and all discussions would be posted in it.

I will of course create a small communities area if you now ask me to. However I'd hate for small and large communities to miss out on the input and experience they can share with each other together.

When you're ready please let me know one way or the other and I'll get things set up for you.

Best wishes

Marc
  The topic has been locked.
<< Start < Prev 1 2 Next > End >>
© 2008 The Movement for Reform Judaism
Joomla! is Free Software released under the GNU/GPL License.